Canada's MMA Forum at Top MMA News

You must be logged in to post Login Register

Register? | Lost Your Password?

Search Forums:


Wildcard Usage:
*    matches any number of characters
%    matches exactly one character

Chemelli vs Penner – 10 Point Must w/ 1/2 points


2:19 pm
September 19, 2011

Keith Grienke


posts 714


I watched this fight live.

Scoring it 10 Point Must
I scored it 29-28 for Nick Penner with Nick winning the first and third with Chemelli winning the second.

Scoring it 10 Point Must with 1/2 Point
I scored round 1 – 10-9 Penner. I thought Penner clearly won. It could almost be 10-8.5 Penner as this was close to being stopped after Penner dropped Chemelli and was ground and pounding him. Figure Chemelli landed some hard ones early, which stopped me from giving it 10-8.5.

I scored round 2 – 10-9 Chemelli. This was a closer round but I thought Chemelli had Penner reeling at times especially from a hard knee strike.

I scored round 3 – 10-9.5 Penner. Boring round where Chemelli moved forward but did not throw anything. Penner landed some jabs. Both extremely tentative.

Penner won 29-28.5 on my score card.

Round 1 was more definitive for Penner than Round 2 was for Chemelli. Not sure if I should have given Penner 10-8.5 there.

I am trying to figure this out. Anyone else watch the fight and want to offer their opinions?

7:16 pm
September 19, 2011

Cj Saftic


posts 40


Yea as far the the 10 point must system goes, I had Penner winning the first and third round with the second being a toss up. In the second I thought both guys had strong points but I could see Chemellli taking it. All in all solid showing from two tough Canadians.

As far the the 10 point must with 1/2….well let's just say im not in favour of this system lol

9:03 pm
September 19, 2011

Keith Grienke


posts 714


I asked Pat Reid if he could share the ECSC 10 point w/ 1/2 points scores from the fights. Not sure if they test scored or if they could share, but worth asking.

If he replies and I am allowed to post them, I will post them here.

11:05 pm
September 19, 2011

Bobby Karimi-Busheri


posts 206


I agree with all that you said Keith

4:49 pm
September 20, 2011

Cj Saftic


posts 40


Yea Keith post it up for sure if you can, I would love to have a look at it

9:05 pm
September 25, 2011

Keith Grienke


posts 714


Never got a response from Pat Reid on this.

10:16 am
September 26, 2011

Cj Saftic


posts 40


Damn, I would be interested in seeing how it works and how they scored Penner vs. Chemelli

No Tags

About the Top MMA News at Forum

Most Users Ever Online: 196

Currently Online:
7 Guests

Currently Browsing this Topic:
1 Guest

Forum Stats:

Groups: 1
Forums: 6
Topics: 2012
Posts: 5903


There are 75723 Members
There have been 4 Guests

There are 3 Admins
There is 1 Moderator

Top Posters:

boygirl – 491
T.J. COLETTI – 300
harry balls – 290
Robin Black – 235
Jamie Locke – 222
Mike Davis – 212
Bobby Karimi-Busheri – 206
Sean Quinn – 196
Tyler Davis – 160
DeViLBoY – 105

Recent New Members: diinowe, atozcrypto, jennyholt, Bitdefendersupportca, Asian tantric


Discussion contents reflect the views of individual participants only. Top MMA News bears no responsibility for accuracy of participant comments and will bear no legal liability for discussion results. By using the Top MMA News forums, you are agreeing to abide by the Top MMA News forum rules.