The Right “Answer”: The Case for an Immediate Frankie Edgar Rematch


I never fail to marvel at the odd, utterly unpredictable process by which MMA fans choose what “controversial” decisions to care about.

Nick Diaz doesn’t get the nod over Carlos Condit? Robbery, I say! Mike Bisping squeaks past Matt Hamill? Home cooking at it’s worst! BJ Penn doesn’t get the decision over GSP? I hate wrestling! GSP’s a cheater! RAHHHHHH!

And yet other times, the chorus of fans is remarkably silent. Ellenberger vs. Sanchez was a razor close decision featuring a possible 10-8 round – yet not a peep was made about that decision. Anthony Pettis, he of showtime kick legend, had an extremely close fight with Jeremy Stephens that no one got too worked up about. I recall lots of talk about “everybody being a winner” when the ref’s raised Dan Henderson’s hand instead of “Shogun” Rua’s – but switch Dan’s hand for Lyoto Machida’s that gets raised instead of Rua’s, it was an affront to the fight gods.

It’s fascinating stuff. You could write a master’s thesis on the psyche of the MMA fan when it comes to close decisions. Case in point: last weekend’s Frankie Edgar vs. Ben Henderson title fight.

Once again, Frankie Edgar put on one hell of a world title fight – and once again, he had to go through Hell to do it. I joked during the event that after all his fights, Frankie must sit backstage in the dressing room, face mashed into hamburger meat, missing teeth as well as brain cells, thinking “This MMA stuff sucks! Why wasn’t I a plumber or something?”

This time, fate wasn’t so kind to Frankie. By fight’s end, both Dana White and myself had scored the fight for Frankie 3 rounds to 2, despite Benson looking like he stepped off a treadmill and Frankie looking like he lost a headbutting contest with a locomotive. When the judges gave Henderson the nod, you could see the disappointment in Frankie’s face (what was left of it, anyways). The 12 hour flight from Japan looking like Elephant man would have been nicer with 12 pounds of gold to cuddle up to.

Fun fact: last night, the reigning lightweight champion for almost two years, who removed the greatest 155’er of all-time from the title picture forever and handed Gray Maynard the only loss that Gray himself didn’t self-inflict, lost his belt in a very close, very fun fight.

Standard MMA playbook clearly indicated where we go from here. Two words: Immediate. Rematch.

Yet you mention this in regards to Frankie and all you get are eye rolls and disappointed sighs. “Frankie keeps rematching people!” the angry fan complains. “I’m tired of Lightweight getting help up by Frankie Edgar fights! It’s not fair to the division. It’s boring! I don’t like Frankie Edgar! BOOOOOO!”

There’s so much wrong with this sentiment that I don’t even know where to start, but let’s start with a question: have you SEEN any of Frankie’s fights recently? His series with gray Maynard is one of the best trilogies in MMA history, if not the best. Maynard vs. Frankie II was the fight of the year last year, and Maynard vs. Edgar III wasn’t far behind.

And before that, Edgar’s series with BJ Penn was a technical masterpiece par excellence. I’ll admit Penn vs. Edgar 1 was a tad slow, but it was hardly a snoozer by any stretch of the imagination. And Penn vs. Edgar 2 was a master class in all-round MMA that showed fully the evolution of Frankie Edgar. Those were fights that were not only entertaining, but significant to the history of MMA. They represented the end of the “BJ Penn” era of the division.

Now the fan complains about too many-immediate rematches. Apparently, the deluge of world-class, FOTY candidates Frankie Edgar has been having while champion are crap because they’ve been with the same people. Let’s get the division moving again, man!

First off: the division is “moving along” just fine. The time spent on the Maynard/Edgar series last year let the division sort itself out after the influx of talent from the WEC. Benson Henderson emerged as a clear #1 contender, and look how that worked out. Anthony Pettis set himself as a potential contender for the title with his win last night, but Jim Miller and Nate Diaz are right on his heels.

My point is there’s still more “sorting” that can be done, allowing time for the UFC to do the right thing, and give Frankie Edgar an immediate rematch against Ben Henderson.

Ok, I shouldn’t say “right thing” because it makes this sound like some holier-than-thou crusade rather than my personal opinion. And really, there’s nothing wrong with giving Pettis the next shot at the belt. He’s a big name, has history with the champion, and will put on guaranteed fireworks. I could see the UFC going that way and I wouldn’t be (too) ticked off about it.

But to my mind, Frankie Edgar has earned his rematch. Whatever you think of his style or the way he wins fights, he’s gutted it out as champion almost two years now – an eternity in MMA – and given us some absolute classics on the process. He deserves a chance to win back the belt he lost in a close decision.

And it was a close decision, folks, no matter what Frankie’s face looked like post-fight. Many fans seem content to judge a fight by how “damaged” a fighter looks afterwards. That’s a fine system I guess, but it’s not the one the judges use to pick a winner. And if we can give GSP the nod over BJ Penn in their first fight, Diego Sanchez the nod over Martin Kampmann, and Leonard Garcia the nod over most anybody, we have to at least consider the notion that Edgar/Henderson II isn’t ridiculous on it’s face.

FightMetric scored the hotly-debated BJ Penn vs. Jon Fitch draw 29-28 for Fitch, with a performance score of 273-159. That’s a 114-point difference. That’s a fight that, if you recall, was scheduled to get an immediate rematch before Jon Fitch took an arrow to the…no!…must…not make….overused…Skyrim joke. I don’t even play Skyrim. What the hell am I talking about?

Right, FightMetric. They scored Bendo vs. Frankie 388-285 in total performance score, while giving the nod on the cards to Benson. That’s a 103-point difference.

What’s my point? In the aforementioned case, a 114-point difference in a draw, in a non-title fight, was enough to merit an immediate rematch. Yet a 103-point difference, in an extremely close, fun world title match…isn’t?

When BJ dropped the belt to Frankie, FightMetric scored it 373-263 total performance rating for BJ Penn. That difference of 90 points was enough to merit a near-automatic immediate rematch with Edgar for Penn. Yet Benson’s 103-point victory over Frankie is a win set in stone, beyond reproach or controversy?

Frankie’s earned his rematch, folks. I’m not saying it has to happen or even that it will. If he has to go to the back of the line, so be it. Life goes on, and I’m sure Pettis vs. Henderson II will be a barnburner.

But some part of me is hoping that the UFC – and MMA fans, to whom they must cater – give the former champ the respect due a man who’s held a title for two years, best a P4P great to get it, and was in last year’s fight of the year.

What more must a man do to earn your guys respect?

9 Responses to “ The Right “Answer”: The Case for an Immediate Frankie Edgar Rematch ”

  1. Josh Oliveira says:

    Penn vs. Fitch and Edgar vs. Maynard II were immediately scheduled to be rematched because they were ruled draws. Penn vs. Edgar I was rematched because Penn was, and remains, the greatest lightweight champion in MMA history. Edgar vs. Bendo should not be rematched immediately because it wasn’t particularly close.

    I’m not sure where the controversy lies?

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 1

  2. Dragon Azteca says:

    Frankie got his ass whooped! who ever wrote this article is obviously a Frankie fan, and I would say to him “stop crying! stop saying damage doesn’t count, and move on!”
    BTW Frankie VS Penn 1, Penn won! so in my book they’re 1-1, also Penn VS GSP 1, Penn also won! Don’t believe me, check the fights again!

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  3. Bendo clearly won this fight. Too many fans call for immediate rematches.

    Well-loved! Thumb up 7 Thumb down 0

  4. WCH says:

    Don’t get me wrong I am a fan of both fighters. I am not sure what the debate is about, clearly Ben won this fight hands down. I don’t think there is a need for an immediate rematch. Edgar should consider dropping down a weight class in my opinion.

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  5. Jamie Locke says:

    I don’t see the need for Edgar to drop down to 45. The guy fights well at LW, he has a great chance at making another run for the belt.

    If he makes another run at the title and doesn’t see success, then maybe concider dropping down, but for now, he is in a good spot at 155lbs IMO.

    Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  6. Elton Hobson says:

    @Dragon…I direct you to the part of my article where I wrote

    “Ok, I shouldn’t say “right thing” because it makes this sound like some holier-than-thou crusade rather than my personal opinion. And really, there’s nothing wrong with giving Pettis the next shot at the belt. He’s a big name, has history with the champion, and will put on guaranteed fireworks. I could see the UFC going that way and I wouldn’t be (too) ticked off about it.”

    So when you tell me to “stop crying”, you’ll forgive me if I don’t know what the sam hell you’re talking about! Seriously dude, this is just my opinion, which I freely admit in my article is the minority one. If I’m crying, it’s only because no one in the comments section so far agrees with me :(

    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

  7. Brando says:

    Round 1- Frankie easily wins based on quantity of strikes. Round 2- Bendo based on damage and some other big shots
    Round 3- really close Frankie dominated last 2 minutes of fight and steals the round. Damn he is tough to take and hold down.
    Round 4- really close again Bendo has a decent guillotine attempt and some hard punches that give him the round.
    Round 5- Frankie lands some solid shots even drops bendo and pushes the pace. Frankie.
    All the damage was done in the 2nd.
    I wanted Bendo to win cause I liked his story. I initially thought bendo won but now after watching it with sound off I give it to Frankie. Frankie is now my favorite fighter too. My questions for everyone is when someone gets a takedown and cant keep the opponent down does he score? Is that equivalent to a solid punch? I don’t think it’s worth much. Give him the rematch that was a hell of a fight.

    Thumb up 0 Thumb down 1

  8. Brando says:

    Ps Love your articles Elton. Very well done and inciteful.

    Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

  9. Bobby Karimi says:


    Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Some HTML is OK